Colour is a powerful influencer. Of all sensations, colour (besides packaging, shape and texture) provides the first real impression that lasts the longest. Colour, which possess no tangible nutritional values, have no role in beverage and drink other than that to deceive. Colour can deceive our taste perception by producing taste differences; differentiations which do not exist. For example, try tasting a crystal clear (free of caramel colourant) cola – most believe it is less sweet and less tasteful. Colour simply is a critical driver behind consumer decision-making.
The purpose of the deceit is to ensure the consumer’s (perceived) enjoyment is maximised (or to become more appealing). For example, we often associate a particular flavour profile before tasting:
Other reasons for adding colourant include:
The use of colourants in food and beverage are carefully controlled under various national legislation. Regulatory bodies in the EU and USA regularly review, publish and regulate a permitted list of colourant for beverage and drink application. It is, therefore, important to investigate the permitted colourant list to ensure product compliance for goods to be manufactured in, or exported to, a specific country.
The use of colourants in beverage and drink (beyond perfecting the colour shade), as with all other ingredients, has to be carefully selected for its performance in the presence of acids, flavours, antioxidants and even preservatives. It is essential that at all stages of development that trials are completed to ensure the stability of the colour.
There are two basic classes in colourant: natural and synthetic (artificial). Natural colours are typically derived from vegetables, fruits, spices, plants, minerals and insects. Below are some of the colourants generally used in beverage and drink:
Source | E Number | CI Number | Stability | Other | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Acid | Heat | Light | |||||
Natural | |||||||
Annatto | Seeds of annatto shrub (Bixa orellana) | E160b | 75120 | P | G | M | Can precipitate in acidic environment |
Beta Carotene | Carrots, algae, palm | E160a | 40800 | G | G | P | Can be synthesized |
Carthamus | Safflower thistle (Carthamus tinctorius L.) | G | G | G | |||
Curcumin | Turmeric (rhizomes of Curcuma longa) | E100 | 75300 | G | G | P | |
Riboflavine | E101 | M | G | G | AKA Vitamin B2 or lactoflavin | ||
Riboflavine-5-phosphate | E101a | G | G | ||||
Lutein | Aztec marigold (Tagetes erecta) | E161b | 75135 | G | G | G | |
Paprika | Red pepper (Capsicum annum L.) | E160c | G | G | G | ||
Lycopene | Red tomatoes (Solanum lycopersicum L.) | E160d | 75125 | G | M | M | |
Apocarotenal | Citrus fruits and vegetables such as spinach | E160e | 40820 | G | G | M | |
Canthaxanthin | E161G | 40850 | M | G | |||
Red Sandalwood | 75540 | G | G | ||||
Anthocyanins | Grape skin, aronia, black carrot, elderberry, red cabbage, hibiscus | E163d-f | G | G | M | Red in acidic solutions; bluer as pH increases | |
Carmine | Cochineal insect (Dactilopius coccus) | E120 | 75470 | G | G | G | Solubility decreases with lowering of pH; will precipitate below pH 3 |
Beet-Red | Red beetroot (Beta vulgaris) | E162 | G | P | M | Stable between pH 3.5 – 5; | |
Copper-chlorophyll | E141 | 75810 | G | G | G | Modified natural extracts | |
Chlorophyll | Green-leafed plants | E140 | 75810 | P | P | G | |
Caramel | E150 | G | G | ||||
Synthetic | |||||||
Quinoline Yellow | E104 | 47005 | G | G | G | ||
Tartrazine | E102 | 19140 | G | G | G | Yellow No. 5 | |
Sunset Yellow | E110 | 15985 | G | G | G | Yellow No. 6 | |
Ponceau 4R | E124 | 16255 | G | G | G | ||
Carmoisine | E122 | 14720 | G | G | G | ||
Amaranth | E123 | 16185 | G | G | M | ||
Allura Red | E129 | 16035 | G | G | G | Red No. 40 | |
Patent Blue V | E131 | 42051 | P | G | M | ||
Indigo Carmine | E132 | 73015 | M | P | P | Blue No. 2 | |
Brilliant Blue FC | E133 | 42090 | G | G | G | Blue No. 1 | |
Food Green S | E142 | 44090 | G | P | |||
Brilliant Black BN | E151 | 28440 | M | M | G |
* E Numbers: in accordance with guidelines of E.EC;
** CI Number Colour Index number allocated by the Society or Dyers & Colourists
It is important that colourants undergo application test, I.e. challenging conditions to ensure best performance and shade delivery throughout the product’s shelf life. Parameters such as shelf life, recipe, packaging and factors such as light, oxidation and acid stability are considered. For example, low pH can affect stability and reducing agents such as ascorbic acid may stabilize carotenoids but destabilize anthocyanins.
The statutory provisions for the use of food colourings and generally on food additives are laid down in Annex II of Regulation (EC) No. 1333/2008 and on flavourings and certain food ingredients with flavouring properties in the Regulation (EC) No. 1334/2008 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 December 2008.
The labeling of colours in food is regulated by the Directive 2000/13/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council on the approximation of the laws of the Member States relating to the labeling, presentation and advertising of foodstuffs.
The purity criteria of colour additives are regulated by the Commission Directive 2008/128/EC laying down specific purity criteria concerning colours for use in foodstuffs.
To be continued//…
[ecm name=’table blogs’]